1 ••• a Drama Desk Award nomination for Township Fever!; and a share of a Grammy Award for producing part of the sound track on Disney's The Lion King (ultimately he was declared ineligible for the award due to a technicality - Coleman). One would have thought that with a track record like this, Ngema was destined to succeed in whatever theatrical enterprise he undertook. What then went wrong? Why did his most recent venture into musical drama fail so abysmally? What ultimately brought him down? A brief recap of his career may be helpful here. After serving a short period of apprenticeship with Gibson Kente, a popular township playwright and director, Ngema made his first big splash by teaming up with another of Kente's perform ers, Percy Mtwa, and creating a series of sketches built on the premise of Jesus Christ's second coming, this time to South Sarafina! cast © Brigitte Lacombe An extensive tour of the townships and black homelands followed, and the fame of Woza Albert! spread. It was an easy play to transport because the props consisted of little more than a couple of crates and a coat rack holding several items of clothing that the actors put on to impersonate various characters. African Quarterly on the Ar Vol GLENDORA Africa. Under the guidance of Barney Simon, an experienced theatre director, their two-man show, originally called Our Father Who Art in Heaven, opened at the Market Theatre in Johannesburg as VVa^o Albert! and immediately made an impact, drawing a larger black audience to that innovative theatrethan any previous production (Jones 1 10). An extensive tour of the townships and black homelands followed, and the fame OF Woza Albert! spread. It was an easy play to transport because th e prop s c on si sted of li ttle more tha n a cou ple of crates a n d a coa t rack hold i n g severa l items of cloth i n g th a t the actors put on to impersonate various characters. To play white men, each actor clapped on a clown's nose—half a squash ball painted pink that was secured around his neck with an elastic band. This was minimalist theatre requir ing no elaborate stage sets, fine costumes or fancy equipment. It could be done anywhere. The play relied entirely on the mimetic talents of the actors, who provided all the sound effects as well as an extraordinary range of visual effects. After proving themselves locally, Ngema and Mtwa took theirshowto Britain, Germany and America, where itcontinued to be a smash hit, winning awards wherever it went. It remained abroad for nearly three years, and in the intervals between tours, Ngema returned to South Africa, founded his own small theatre company called Committed Artists, and trained a group of young men in performance techniques. He has said in 1983I established Committed Art ists with the sole aim oi naming young, disadvantaged South Africans. My methodology entailed a combination of Western and African theatrical techniques. Grotowsky, Stanislavsky and Peter Brook were the main Western influences on my method, particularly with their experimental theatre (what Peter Brook called the immediate theatre). The African sphere was the most accented, especially the Zulu culture. This is what made this method unique, for A fr ica n h fe a n d m ovemen t has a rhythm of Hi Own (Ng ema viij In 1 985 Committed Artists launched their first production, Asinamali! (We have no money!), in a cinema in Soweto then moved it downtown to the Market Theatre before embarki ng on very succe ssful nati o n a l a n d inter nati o n al lour \ As inamali! had the same kind of intense energy that distinguished Woza Albert!, butit made much greater use of song, d ance and tightly organised ensemble work. It also dealt in an unusual manner with the tragic lives of five men impr isoned after the assassination of a pr om i ne n t str i ke leader. Peter Brook saw the production in Harlem and was struck by its dynamism, noting that If you approach a situation like the South African one naturalistically, you can't present terrible events Me these inany other than a tragic, sentimental way. The events in their very nature are tragic or sentimentality-producing events. But what I found profoundly right and extraordinary about Asinamali! was thatthis hen tfymg uruatiao was being presented, pitilessly through a joie de vivre The events were not softened by it but AfricanQuar on GLENPORA . Vol. 2/No 2 heightened to the bit degree because they were presented, not through a sentimentality, but through a vitality. (Jones I 14-15) Ngema was not one of the performers m this play, but he had trained all the actors, written the script, composed the songs, and choreographed the dances. Asinamali! was his first great success as a director-produ cer,andhe often tra velled with the company when they performed in America, Europe, japan and Australia, a tour that lasted more than two years. Whenever he returned to South Africa, he went out and searched for fresh talent, simultaneously recruiting experienced theatre professionals to help him with his next show, which he decided would celebrate South Africa's black schoolchildren who were then leading the struggle against apartheid. He rounded up twenty teenagers, 'moved them into a four-room house in Daveytown, near Johannesburg, lived with them, and trained them vocally, mentally and physically' (Jones 1 24). At the same time he developed a script, composing songs and writing lyrics as he went along. After fourteen months of hard work and fine tuning, the result was Sarafinal, his most ambitious undertaking and by far his most remunerative. After opening to great applause at the Market Theatre, Ngema in 1987 took his cast of twenty-three youngsters to Lincoln Centre in New York where their engagement was extended repeatedly until they moved to Broadway and played to capacity audiences at the Cort Theatre for the next eighteen months (Jones 129). 'Sarafina! WAS probably the highlight of my career,' Ngema has said, adding, 'Ironically, it was the least sophisticated of all my work ' (Lee 34). The story-line, he admitted, 'is not strong. IVj very simplistic...[But] I did it deliberately. I was telling it through the eyes of the kids. And those kids, wearing those uniforms,. people just loved them. It's easier to love young people than adults on stage...For the first time in South Africa, we saw a young professional cast. We saw a Broadway musical played by kids, who, even though they were young, were highly professional. You see, it's not so much the story but how its done!' (Berman 32). It could be said that at that point in his career, Ngema seemed to be doing everything nghi He was offered recording contracts, an Academy-Award winning director made a fulllength documentary about Sarafina!, and then came the Hollywoodversion of the musical with megastar Whoopi Goldberg m a leading role. This feature film, shot in the environs of Soweto, employed about 100 actors and up to 5000 extras (Makgabutlane 1 was fascinated by the idea that people without any criminal record could be compelled to commit gruesome acts totally out of chaf Oder with theirpersonalities and their morality under the forces of. ..a 'pressure cooker situation'... The desperation of these workers gotme... Township Fever! is about music, about Johannesburg, about Soweto, about Mshengu Village, about the homelands and about how our environment plays upon us. Apartheid dehumanises the oppressed —b utitalsodehu man ises the oppressors. (Ngema 128- 29) To get th i s me ssage mass, Ngema relied on his usual bag of tricks: lively mbaqanga music, energetic dancing, athletic performances, a mixture of sentiment and joie de vivre—the kind of theatrical experience Peter B r o o k recognised as poiisiting 'vitality ' In an interview Ngema explained his 'philosophy of theatre' this way: I think it is because I am a musician that I tend to have the kind of approach I have. When theatre does not have a beat, does not have a rhythm, then theatre tends to bore. Theatre rrtuu be like a piece of music which has a beat that people can sit and listen to. ..or dance to. And wi thi n that beat th ere are so many other co lo urs you put in. But first and foremost, theatre should entertain. When people are entertained, then they will be informed and enlightened. The vehicle we use is entertainment, first of all. (Makgabutlane I990:20) However, at this point in his career, given his past successes, the audience he appears to have sought most avidly to entertain was an international one, and this may have led him to blunt the political force of his message. In interviews published a few weeks after Township Fever! opened, he stated. At'H-nn Qumlarfy i>n (hit A m mssmmi lib) I GLENDORA 1| You see, when people pay $70 for a ticket, they do not want to hear about the sufferings of black people from a strange country in Africa. They want to be entertained. (Mendel 18) They are not gonna be bored by you telling them about your struggle in South Africa. They don't care about South Africa. Those peop le want to go and see a good theatre p iece. Finished. Whether it's a South African piece, a Jamaican piece, 0 British piece, they just want to see good theatre. In fact, they are a harder audience to entertain. Most of the time they do not see political theatre anyway; they refuse to go to fringe theatre in New York City. They do not go off-Broadway or off-off Broadway because they don't want to hear politics. Those are the ladies with fur coats. (Makgabutlane 1990: 24) By now Ngema may have been aiming his productions at New York ladies in fur coats rather than at his own peopie. Certainly he had hiseye on the main chance—a production that would culminate m a screen adaptation, just as Sarafina! had. In a 1 9 9 2 interview he said,' The story told in Township Fever ! (Which followed m the footsteps of Sarafina!) h a more powerful story. I am at the moment talking with studios in Hollywood. If someone came to me and said, "Here's RIO million, let's make a movie," I would go for it' (Makgabutlane 1992 40). Money, in fact, had become a major preoccupation for him at the very height of his success, when he was simultaneously touring two Sarafina! companies, negotiating film rights for the Whoopi Goldberg production, and training the large troupe of actors in Township Fever! 'My company is funding itself on huge budgets,' he exclaimed. 'Before we staged Township Fever! we were talking half a million!' (Mendel 19) He had other projects up his sleeve, too. Asked in 1990 what his plans were, he said, I wish I had more money. I want to start my own record company. In fact, I am in the pro-ess of doing it It might take a year or two. And then maybe later go in to movies' (Ma kg abut lane 1990:24), Five years afterwards asked 'whatsingle thing would improve the quality of your life?' his answer was unequivocal: 'Money, money, money' (Metsoamere B} Not that he hadn't already made a small fortune. In fact by 1994 he had earned enoughto buy hmself an ice house with a kidney-shaped swimm ing pool and a sunken tennis court in an affluence white community in Bryanston, a suburb north of Johannesburg (Jones 144-46). A year later he hadalsofulfilled his dream of starting a record company, Mbongeni Productions, which has by now produced at least four albums and CDS (Anon , Tribute 10), and he had launched a film company as well, Mbongeni Ngema Films, which currently has two films inthe pipeline, one of them based onthelifeof Winnie Mandela (Isaacson 2) In addition he recently published a llection of his musical librettos colled The Best of Mbongeni African Quarterly on the Arts GLENDORA ••. Vo\ ZNv 2 Ngema, and since January 1994 he has been serving as a salaried director of musical theatre at Durbqni Noipl Playhouse, where three of his own new musicals have been produced. All in all, one could say that life has not been unkind to Mbongeni Ngema. And to give him his due, one could have to concede that he certainly has taken full advantage of the opportunities available to him, capitalising on them whenever he could. He has worked very hard and he has prospered. But ever since the original Sarafina! caught the world's attention and made him a wealthy man, his career has been on a downward trajectory. The trouble started with Township Fever ! which offended the leadership of COSATU, the labour union federation that had ordered the execution of the scabs killed during the 1987 railway strike. Ngema was accused by union officials of co-opting, 'for his own commercial gain, a major event in the people's struggle' and of personalising a communal tragedy by adapting it to his own life as a musician (Jones 148-49). Drama critics also didn't like the show, feeling Ngema had 'devoted too much energy to the music and not enough to the script, which badly needed editing. A few critics suggested that he should have delegated some of the work to collaborators' (Jones 151). He was simply trying to take on too much and, as a consequence, was losing creative control of his own gigantic production. It wasn't a matter ofhimbeingtoobig for his britches; the problem was the reverse: his britches were too big for him. His next show, Magic at 4 a m was another musical extravaganza, this one originally inspired by Muha mmadAll' s 1974 fight against George Foreman in Zaire. In fact, it was at first envisioned simplistically as a South African tribute to the champ (Jones 163), a kind of black rocky, the sort of show that would have tremendous box-office appeal and motion picture potential. Ngema invited his biographer Laura Jones to collaborate on the libretto, and her concluding chapter in Nothing Except Ourselves, describing the shaping of the production, is the fullest account available in print of Ngema's characteristic modus operandi. HE usuaiiy starts with a vague concept—in this case one prom oted by a meet i ng with Al i an d h i s ha nd le r s, who atten ded the New York premiere of the Hollywood film of Sarafina! He then seeks backing for the development of the script (provided at the outset by a theatre in New Jersey), negotiates a suitable venue for the performance (this time the mammoth, 1,1 00-seat Civic T W F B instead of the smaller Market Theatre), assembles a large company (well over f,hy rot including lovers, families, and other hangers-on,' Jones 166), and starts putting them through drill ('doing calisthenics, singing scales, and learning dances,' Jones 168) before actually tackling the task of writing the book, music and lyrics his Committed Artists would per form. But once he has a deadline for his show, he goesat it Mlthrottle. Jones rapom ,Kor he and she brainstormed on a