Africa Media Review Vol. 1. No. 1. 1966 African Council on Communication Education. The Mass Media Systems of Kenya and Tanzania: A Comparative Analysis >y Dele Ogunade bslract The article is a comparative study of the mass media systems of Kenya id Tanzania. The author examines the historical, geographical, political, economic, >cial and cultural factors which shape the mass media systems in the two ountries. The article concludes that the factors of literacy and politico-economic ^stem are destined to have significant impact on the future growth and lape of the mass media in Kenya and Tanzania. e same Cet article est une etude comparative des systemes de media au Kenya et en anzanie. L'auteur examine les facteurs historiques geographiques, politiques, conomiques et culturels aux contours desquels sont organises les systemes des eux pays. L'article a conclut que l'alphabetisation et le systeme politique et conomique auront un impact significatif sur la croissance et la forme des lass media au Kenya et en Tanzanie. Dele Oeunade is a lecturer at the Department of Mass Communication, University of Lagos, Nigeria. 99 Introduction: A comparative study of the mass media systems of two countries musi take account of the historical, geographical, political, economic, social anc cultural factors which shape the mass media systems in the two countries. | This is because, as several scholars have noted, the nature of a country's history, population, geography, and politico-economic system goes a long way toward explaining the characteristics of its mass media.1 Against such al background, this study offers a comparative analysis of the mass medial systems of Kenya and Tanzania - two adjacent African nations sharing al related history dating back to the pre-colonial era, a common culture andl ethnic makeup, and a common set of geographical and natural conditions) that bear on the day-to-day lives of their people. Since attaining nationhood in the early 1960s, Kenya and Tanzania havel received the attention of students of African politics and development! because of the divergent conceptions of development each has chosen to I pursue. Analyses of the societal institutions of these divergent conceptions! of development have invariably involved an analysis of the mass media f systems of both nations. Consequently, there is a body of literature on the | mass media of both nations. Literature Review Kenya and Tanzania mass media systems have been the objects of several I studies. Hachten looked at the Kenyan press under a one-party form of I government and expressed reservation about the degree of freedom the ' press enjoys.2 James F. Scotton, who has studied the Kenyan mass media extensively, detailed the unusual success of African-language papers in a continent still dominated by a press in English, French, and other European languages.3 He observes pointedly that in a developing multi-lingual nation such as Kenya, successful and popular publication in a lingua franca such as Swahili are extremely important for national integration; Scotton further analyzed the patterns of readership and ownership of Kenya's four major newspapers controlled by two non-African owners.4 He found that both in content and readership, these newspapers are usually divided not along ownership lines but along language lines, two being published in English and two in Swahili. These language lines are also major boundaries of Kenya's racial and socio-economic groups. Peter Mwaura's Communication Policies in Kenya is perhaps the most comprehensive survey of Kenya mass media to date. Both in breath and depth, Mwaura's study examines the Kenya mass media in relation to 100 the historical, political, social and economic development of the Kenyan nation. Mwaura recognizes the largely underdeveloped state of the Kenya mass media but contends that the mass media, as a"vital and integral part of Kenya's development strategy," are likely to grow if "they address more directly the interests and concerns of thewananchi and,at the same time the literacy base is widened."5 In a study of mass media development in Tanzania, Graham L. Mytton outlines the problems of the mass media vis-a-vis the country's geography, population distribution, economics, literacy, and political history.6 He found that the mass media, although a very recent phenomena, have already played an important role in the development of national consciousness. Mytton concludes that people in the remotest village are today brought into daily contact with the political events that earlier would have taken weeks to reach them, if indeed they ever reached them at all. John C. Condon, in a study of nation building and image building in the Tanzanian press, found that the press mirrors the political consciousness of a newly independent state and reflects some of the ambiguities that accompany political articulation in a one-party democracy.7 Analyzing four daily newspapers, Condon devotes special attention to the "new geography" which is presented on an attempt to anticipate the world image or "psychological geography" which results from reading the daily newspaper. Condon concludes that the selection of what news to print reflects the tensions and conflicts between an ideal news policy and the limitations imposed by the lack of funds, personnel, and the influence of the western news services. Condon and Neher, in a comparative study of the mass media and nation building in Kenya and Tanzania, pointed out that such forms of traditional cultural expression as drama, literature, and dance are possible media for creating an ambience for the emergence of a national culture.8 Contending that mobilization of a national consciousness, to supersede regional and ethnic consciousness, is partially a function of communication, Condon and Neher concluded that those which are characterized by immediacy - radio, television, film - can be most effective in the political mobilization process. In an analysis of the role^of the Tanzania press in the formation of foreign policy, Okwudiba Nnoli found the press generally supportive of government policies.9 According to Nnoli , the foreign news content of Tanzania newspapers appeared to be sketchy, crisis oriented, and lacking in any serious analyses. In his analysis of the role of the mass media in developing countries, N. Ngwanakilala, in Mass Communication and Development of Socialism 101 According to Joel D. Barkan, a scholar of Kenyan and Tanzanian politics, some of the significant benefits attributable to Kenya's History as a colony with a large European settlement were: (1) extensive development of cash crop, (2) larger and more developed urban areas, and (3) greater expenditures by the colonial government on schools, roads, and other public services.14 Another benefit was the establishment of modern mass media in Kenya long before Tanzania.15 Unlike Kenya, Tanzania's very small European settler community, high illiteracy of the African population, and the late development of African nationalism all combined to slow the introduction and development of the mass media. However, this lateness worked to Tanzania's advantage in that from their inception the media catered for the African population.16 Geography To understand aspects of a country's media, Merrill and Lowenstein posit that the size of a country, the physical barriers to overland communication, and the location of major cities are important elements.17 A look at the maps of Kenya and Tanzania shows the differences in size, location of major cities, and physical barriers to overland communications. With an area of 364,900 square miles, Tanzania includes the highest and lowest parts of Africa which are great barriers to communication. Tanzania's size, relatively low population density (40 per square mile), few urban centers, and scattered rural population have all influenced aspects of its mass media. For example, daily newspapers are urban oriented and large capital expenditures are required to bring radio signals to the scattered rural population. In contrast, Kenya because of its small size does not suffer from Tanzania's geographical disabilities. With an area of 219,788 square miles, Kenya is mainly extensive plains dotted here and there by hills and Mount Kenya. Unlike Tanzania, Kenya's population density is high, reaching more than 1,000 persons per square mile in the South-Western quardrant of the country. Approximately 75 per cent of the population is contained in only 10 per cent of Kenya. This concentration of the population has made the task of communicating with the people easier and cheaper. Despite the concentration of the population, newspapers in Kenya and Tanzania are urban oriented. 103 Population: The population maps of Kenya and Tanzania illustrate the differences peculiar to each country in terms of size, urbanization, languages spoken, education and affluence. Kenya has the advantages of its population being largely concentrated in an area easy to reach and its capital Nairobi, being situated near the center of this populated area. Tanzania is not that fortunate. Mytton captures succinctly Tanzania's communication problems with wildly scattered, un-urbanized population.18 A compensating factor that Tanzania enjoys over Kenya is the widespread use and understanding of the national language, Swahili. This factor has laid the basis for cultural and political integration of Tanzania's scattered population. Swahili is widely spoken and understood in Kenya but no means universally. The high illiteracy, little urbanization, and low per capital income of the masses of Kenya and Tanzania have combined to stunt the growth of the press and make radio the pervasive medium it is today.19 For instance, by 1984 the highest circulation attained by a daily in either country was 100,572 by Kenya's Daily Nation. Politico-Economic System Besides having the same pre-independence British colonial master, Kenya and Tanzania are both one-party states. The ruling parties in both countries at independence gradually became the only parties: the Kenya African National Union (KANU) in Kenya and the Tanganyika African National Union renamed the Chama Cha Mapinduzi (The Revolutionary Party (CCM) in Tanzania. There the similarity ends. In the years immediately following independence, Kenya and Tanzania have pursued divergent politico-economic policies with both being perceived as prototypes, of capitalist and socialist developments respectively. To be specific, Tanzania has committed itself to building a socialist society through the 1967 Arusha Declaration which stressed national self-reliance. In contrast,Kenya has sought to develop its political economy on the basis of patron-client capitalism with private enterprise and foreign finance playing an important role.20 As it is to be expected, the mass media systems of both nations reflect their politico-economic realities. For one thing, Tanzania's mass media, mostly state owned, are more politicized than Kenya because of the important role they have been assigned in the political education of the masses. In particular, they supplement the activities of CCM in the 104 encouragement of hard work and self-reliance, and in teaching people about their role in the developing country.21 In contrast, the privately owned Kenya press does not take such explicit ideological stands. The Press Although it is the first of the modern mass media to be established in Kenya and Tanzania, the press today remains a medium with a limited audience largely because of high illiteracy and distribution problems.22 Burdened by the disabilities arising from developing economics, the Kenya and Tanzania press continue to play a useful albeit limited role in the affairs of their countries. Table 1 compares the vital statistics of the Kenyan and Tanzanian daily press. The daily papers in both nations are complemented by a battery of weeklies, fortnightlies and monthlies published in Swahili and English. The principal ones in Kenya are Sunday Nation (100,902), Taifa Weekly (63,012), Chemsha Bongo (10,000); and Weekly Review (25,000). Both nations have expanding rural newspapers to satisfy the information needs of the rural population. Tanzania is reportedly "experimenting with the largest and most ambitious rural newspaper project in East Africa" and its Swahili monthly Elimu Haina Mwisho (Education has no end), with a circulation of 100,000, is the "largest circulating rural newspaper."23 A content analysis of the daily press showed that "the 'news geography' for the Kenyan press is comparable to that presented in the Tanzanian press. The Swahili press tends to focus on national Or local items with heavy emphasis on speeches by government officials and other political figures. The emphasis in the newspapers of both languages in both countries is on news from or about their own country."24 A feature of the daily newspapers published in Tanzania is that they are highly politicized. According te the editor of one of the papers, "We preach and exhort about 90 per cent of the time "25 This prompted this elaboration from Condon, a scholar of the Tanzanian press: "If President Nyerere is officially the Teacher (Mwalimu) of the nation, the party press is the Preacher."26 Because of their politicization and the socialist ideology of the nation, the Tanzanian papers do not have "a 'society page' or column on the social life of 'national personalities.'"27 In addition, the Tanzanian press does not carry "any photographs or stories about weddings, engagements, baptisms, 'sundowners' or dinner parties."28 Finally, the poetry, written by readers and published daily, is a unique feature of the Swahili language-press. 105 Condon estimates that occasionally as much as 25 per cent of the Swahili papers are devoted to poetry, usually in praise of the nation, the leaders, Africa, or attacking colonialism.29 In contrast, the Kenya press though not party politicized is ideologically partisan. According to Mwaura, the Kenya press "lacks a well-defined concept of what is African about it. It is elitist and urban-oriented. It is Western in orientation "30 Radio and Television Although Kenya and Tanzania show contrasting patterns of public and private ownership and operation of news papers, neither deviates from the standard African practice of state ownership and control of radio broadcasting. This practice is due partly to the pattern of radio control in colonial times. Additionally, Ainslie notes that there is a belief throughout Africa that radio is a powerful instrument of political control and that possession of the broadcasting facilities confers legitimacy on the regime in power.31 In Kenya, radio broadcasting and television are operated under the control of the Kenya government through the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, and is known as the Voice of Kenya (VoK). Programmes for the whole country originate from Nairobi and are relayed by other stations located in Mombasa, Timboros, Nandi Hills, and Kisumu. The main languages used in radio broadcast are Swahili and English, but programmes are also broadcast in 16 local languages. Television was launched in Kenya in October 1962. Through expansion, most of the country now is blanketed. The main languages of TV programs are English and Swahili and the TV stations are on the air for about 38 hours per week. Local programmes occupy about 60 per cent of total transmissions. Both radio and TV broadcasts are steadily increasing amount of advertising though there is a policy banning the broadcast of programmes with explicit violence, shooting or murder, sex, or other activities considered inimical to the social health of the nation.32 The government waived the payment of the annual radio and television license fees since the beginning of the 1970/1971 financial year. This probably resulted in increased ownership of radio and TV sets. A 1972 survey showed that there were about 35,000 TV sets and 1,050,000 radio sets in use in Kenya.33 By 1981, there were an estimated 1.6 million radio receivers and 100,000 TV sets in use. Radio Tanzania is a department of the Ministry of Information and Tourism, which took over broadcasting from the Tanganyika Broadcasting 106 Corporation. Radio Tanzania broadcasts three main services: the national, commercial, and external services. At present, Radio Tanzania does not broadcast in any regional or ethnic languages. The national and commercial services are entirely in Swahili. Though music and light entertainment continue to be the main fares of the national services, the requirement that at least 70 per cent of the music has to be of East African origin gives the national service a distinct Tanzanian flavor.34 Radio Tanzania's external service is more politicized and reflects Tanzania's commitment to the liberation struggles in Southern Africa. Most major liberation movements of Southern Africa are provided free broadcast time. This is in marked constrast to what obtains in Kenya. Condon's survey of Tanzania's communication systems indicates that radio is probably the country's most important means of disseminating news. In answer to the question on their favourite kind of radio programme, 55 per cent said news.35 No accurate and up-to-date data are available on the number of radio and TV sets in use in Tanzania. In 1969, radio licenses were abolished to encourage set ownership. By 1981, an estimated 500,000radio receivers and 7,200 TVsets inZanzibar were inuse in Tanzania. The Tanzanian government has held back on the introduction of television partly out of a desire to wait until it has the capacity for local production.36 News Agencies Both nations' press, radio and television are serviced by fledgling national news agencies. The Kenya News Agency (KNA), established in 1963, is responsible for gathering local news and has offices all over the country. KNA transmits more local news than the local media can use on any given day and has purchased interception rights from the major news agencies. Tanzania's national news agency, Shihata, operates on similar lines as KNA though it does not operate a picture service for local newspapers as KNA does. Several major international news agencies have offices in both nations' capitals but more of these offices are located in Nairobi. * Traditional Mass Media Leonard Doob, in his discussion of "basic" media, refers to clothes or fashions of dress as also a traditional means of communication in Africa.37 While modern mass media are pervasive, the last few years have seen increasing stress on the use of traditional media for communicating political 107 Newspapers Ownership Language Daily Circulation Founded City of Publication Comparison of Daily Newspapers in Kenya and Tanzania Daily Nation Private English 100,572 1960 Nairobi Taifa Leo The Standard Kenya Leo Private Private KANU Swahili English Swahili * * 49,000 32,000 1960 1983 1902 Nairobi Nairobi Nairobi * * Figures not available. Kipanga Kenya Times Daily News Govt. Govt. KANU Swahili English English * * * * 39,000 1964 1972 1983 Zanzibar Nairobi Dar es Salaam Table 1 Uhuru CCM Swahili 100,000 1962 Dar es Salaam or developmental goals. Thus public speeches, rallies, demonstration, dances, oral literature and group singing are regularly employed in Kenya and Tanzania to communicate contemporary messages and further national integration. For instance, "the singing of songs like 'Mungu Ibariki Afrika' (God Bless Africa) or rKanu Yajenga Nchi' (KANU builds the Nation) has beocme a means of communicating political solidarity and legitimacy by political parties in Kenya and Tanzania."38 According to Neher and Condon, "Songs in political campaigns are particularly important in countries like Kenya and Tanzania because political advertising over the national mass media is either prohibited or prohibitively expensive."39 And Mwaura asserts that since it is Kenyan official policy to receive and promote African culture, "It has become common place for communities and groups to communicate with government leaders and politicians through traditional dancing, songs and folklors - and messages are unmistakable and compelling."40 Summary and Conclusion An attempt was made to assess comparatively the mass media of Kenya and Tanzania within the context or those factors which impinged on their growth and present status. Differences and similarities were noted. The dynamic changes daily taking place in developing nations like Kenya and Tanzania mean nothing including#the mass media as discussed in this study is fixed and inalterable. It seems the factors of literacy and politicoeconomic systems are destined to have signifcant impact on the future growth and shapes of the mass media in Kenya and Tanzania. REFERENCES 1. See John Merrill and Ralph Lowenstein, Media, Messages and Men; Siebert et al, Four Theories of the Press and John Condon, "Some Guidelines for Mass Communication Research in East Africa," Gazette 14:141-151 (1968). 2. William A. Hachten, Muffled Drums, (Ames, Iowa: The Iowa State University Press, 1974). 3. James F. Scotton"Kenya's Much Maligned Nationalist Press," Journalism Quarterly 52:30-36 (Spring 1975). 4 "The Press in Kenya a Decade after Independence: Patterns of Readership and Ownership," Gazette 21:19-33 (1975). 109 5. Peter Mwaura, Communication Policies in Kenya, (Paris: UNESCO, 1980), p. 94. 6. Graham L. Mytton, "Tanzania: The Problems of Mass Media Development," Gazette 14:89-100 (1968). 7. John C. Condon, "Nation Building and Image Building in the Tanzania Press," The Journal of Modern African Studies, Vol. 5, No. 3, 1967, pp. 335-54. 8. William W. Neher and John C. Condon, "The Mass Media and Nation-Building in Kenya and Tanzania," in The Search for National Integration in Africa, David R. Smock and Kwamena Bentsi-Enchill, eds., (New York:The Free Press, 1976), pp. 220-239. 9. Okwudiba Nnnoli, Self-Reliance and Foreign Policy in Tanzania, (New York: NOK Publishers International Ltd., 1972), pp. 37-39. 10. N. Ngwanakilala, Mass Communication and Development of Socialism in Tanzania, (Dar-es-Salaam: Tanzania Publishing House, 1981), p. 50. 11. See J.F. Maitland-Jones, Politics in Africa: The Former British Territories, (New York: W.W. Norton and Company Inc., 1973); Kimambo and Temu, A History of Tanzania; Gertzel et al., Government, Politics in Kenya. 12. Mutton "Tanzania: The Problems of Mass Media Development," pp. 89-91. 13. Ibid. 14. Barkan and Okumu, Politics, p. 36 15. Mytton, "Tanzania: The Problems," p. 90. 16. Head, Broadcasting in Africa, p. 62 17. Merrill and Lowenstein, Media Messages and Men, p. 55. 18. Mytton, "Tanzania: The Problems," p. 91. 19. Condon, "Some Guidelines," p. 147. 20. Barkan and Okumu, Politics. 21. Neher and Condon, "The Mass Media and Nation," p. 229-230. 22. Ibid., p. 232. 23. UNESCO, Rural Journalism in Africa, (Paris: Unesco, 1981). 24. Condon, "Nation Building and Image Building," p.152. 25. Ibid., p. 351. 26. Ibid., p. 352. 27. Ibid., p. 350. 28. Ibid. 29. Ibid. 30. Mwaura, Communication Policies in Kenya, p. 62. 110 31. Ainslie, The Press in Africa, p. 152. 32. Head, Broadcasting in Africa, p. 58. 33. Kenya: A Land of Contrasts, (Nairobi: Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, 1974), p. 42. 34. Mytton, "Tanzania: The Problems," p. 97. 35. Neher and Condon, "The Mass Media and Nation," p. 235. 36. Ibid., p. 236 37. Leonard Doob, Communication in Africa, (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1966). 38. Neher and Condon, "The Mass Media and Nation," p. 225. 39. Ibid. 40. Mwaura, Communication Policies in Kenya, p. 35. I l l